top of page

Great Expectations, Very Little Support

Writer: Rachel Roberts
Rachel Roberts
Nov 9
4 min read

Expectations of fathers have changed. The support hasn’t caught up.

Our expectations of fathers have changed a LOT, especially over the past few decades, and that’s wonderful. We tend to want dads working more reasonable hours, being home and more present, hands-on with the babies and household, showing up as truly equal partners as much as possible.

Here’s what we’re missing... All of that rising expectation arrived around the same time in history as a lot of (understandable) frustration with the old-fashioned patriarchal systems, and “men” are now often the punching bags for that history (a topic for another rant another day). Online, and in social groups, that frustration often turns into a general ridicule and impatience with men.

As partners and new parents ourselves, we generally don’t have the bandwidth to hold the concerns or struggles of our teammate dads. And this societal expectation that men should just figure it out and stop bothering us for help bleeds over into our own expectations of them as partners.

So picture a brand-new dad, doing something his own father was never asked to do. Just like a new mom, he’s struggling and not sure if he’s doing a good job. He gets brave and says out loud or online, “I’m struggling with this. I don’t know how to step in and be a better dad, or how to help my partner and do all of this well.” What he often hears back is “Figure it out!” Or “Just look around - it’s obvious what needs to be done!” Or “The patriarchy hurt you man, that’s not my problem.” Or “If you would just get some therapy, this would be easier for you.”

Paternal mental health campaigner Mark Williams, writing for Bright Horizons, describes a similar reaction when dads admit they’re depressed: “What’s he got to be depressed about?” being a typical response. Little empathy. Little acknowledgement of how yes, being a new parent is quite tough and one of the biggest challenges in your life, and oh by the way, it just reshapes your entire identity.

There’s even a word for this: patrescence (the transition of becoming a father), a real concept right alongside matrescence (the transition of becoming a mother). A brief search on the internet shows 96 research papers on matrescence and 4 on patrescence. We are getting better at recognizing how much support new mothers need, but dads? Meh. They need to just figure out how they’re supposed to show up on their own.

We want him in the trenches with mom, but when he reaches for support, we are closing the door and saying it’s his own fault if he can’t figure out how to do it well.

And it’s not just my impression. In a 2026 report from Advocates for Children of New Jersey, most of the 64 fathers interviewed said they’d been judged and stigmatized when trying to be more involved. Researchers in Wales who spoke with 97 dads heard that many feel overlooked and unsupported. They weren’t asking for special treatment, just to be included (University of South Wales, 2026).

It’s not just in our social circles. The health system has the same blind spot. A 2026 survey of more than 1,200 Australian dads found about 60% were never asked about their mental health during pregnancy or the first year after birth (Movember, “More Than a Provider”). And the need is real. About 1 in 10 new dads experience depression during pregnancy or the first year after birth, according to a major JAMA analysis of 43 studies (Paulson & Bazemore, 2010), and later analyses have found similar rates (Rao et al., 2020). New moms have been routinely screened since 2010, and Dr. Craig Garfield says we need to apply the same strategy to dads (Lurie Children’s Hospital, 2025).

A survey of 261 fathers found 51% felt uninvolved or left out during prenatal appointments, and 67% said they were still struggling with their mental health long after becoming a parent. One respondent wanted “acknowledgment from healthcare professionals that dads even exist” (Mair & Williams, Dad Info). This lack of support does not make better dads. It makes quiet, isolated ones.

The research also says fathers’ self-esteem tends to rise with fatherhood - unless they feel criticized. Our words matter more than we realize. And our collective words send a clear message - we’re not going to step in and help you figure out how to be more involved. You just have to do it by yourself, and if not, we can provide some choice words about how much you’re failing to step up as a man and partner.

I will say all day long that mamas need more support. AND dads need it, too. This isn’t a competition. Our teammates are flailing in their new positions. How do we get better at doing this together? The dads in that last survey had some ideas: online support, information, education, and support groups, plus health professionals who actively engage with them as they become parents (Mair & Williams, Dad Info).

Fathers, this gig is harder than they told you it would be. Reaching out for support is part of the job. 💛 I hope we can start getting better at giving it to you.


(Originally shared on my Substack)

Comments


bottom of page